Earring Backs – The Choices Available With Pro’s and Con’s

Screw-back-Sterling Silver CZ 4 mm stud earrings for children

* Disclosure: *Some of the links on this website are affiliate links*. This means that if you click on the links and make a purchase we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases. All Amazon links are affiliate links. This helps support our small blog.*

Types of Earring Backs

There are a multitude of earring claps types available to wear to secure your earrings, using different materials.

Most of us wear the earring backs that come with the earrings we purchase (usually a Scroll or Butterfly type).  However, there are many more designs that may be more suitable,  and are more comfortable to wear that you can interchange with different earrings.

It’s important to chose earring backs made of precious metals for any healing piercing, or wear sleeper earrings which have no backs.

There are earring backs that are more suited to wearing with heavier earrings, with a more sturdy fit,  designed in such a way so as not to pull on your earlobe.   

There are earring backs which will hold your earring more securely therefore are perfect for very precious earrings. Which are the best earring backs  for diamond studs? 

There are also jewellery findings that prevent hook earrings from slipping from your ear.  Are rubber earring backs good?

In this review we attempt to cover as many earring backs as we can think of,  with their advantages and disadvantages. We look at the top earring back replacements.

Spoiler Alert! We recommend the best earring backs for overall comfort and security … that would be LOX, Chrysmela or Omega fittings.  

We sell almost these earring backs in our shop and on our website.

Table of Contents

Scrolls or Butterfly Backs

These are the most common types of earring backs.  Most pierced earrings with a post style earrings  come with butterfly backs. 

GENUINE 925 STERLING SILVER Butterfly backs/scrolls - Big enough to fit standard stud earrings. 5 PAIRS in BRANDED GIFT BOX, BT…

Butterfly backs are also commonly called ‘Scrolls‘ or ‘Friction’ Backs or, less frequently, ‘Push’ Backs.

The design of butterfly backs is that they have a small curl, or scroll, which sits either side of the earring post, which expands and hold tight to earring posts.

They come in a variety of sizes and in a colour to match the earring – most people prefer larger backs, although the smaller backs are more cost-effective if made in gold. 

Straight earring posts (known as a French Fitting) often have one or two little grooves on the post itself, which is designed for the scroll or butterfly to “sit” into.

Choose the position most comfortable for your ear lobe.

Available Materials

If you find you are allergic to costume jewellery or plated metals, use precious metals in your butterfly back earrings. 

Even although the backs are not going through your skin like an earring post is, you’ll soon notice the back of your ear lobe becoming irritated to a non-precious metal earring back against your skin if you are sensitive.  

If the earring back loosens there is a danger that you may lose the earring as well. This can happen if the earring gets caught on your hair or clothing, as can happen when you pull an item of clothing over your head.

Please take your earrings out before you undress – one of the most common and regrettable things we hear in our shop from customers is how they’ve lost one of their favourite earrings after it was inadvertently pulled out.

There’s a possibility that butterfly backs trap bacteria – it’s important to remove your earrings regularly and clean the earrings including the back to remove debris and dirt.

Pro’s

  • Easy to use and wear
  • Available in any jewellers
  • Inexpensive in silver or plastic
  • Available in any jewellers

Con’s

  • Can become loose over time
  • Can be lost easily
  • Butterfly backs trap bacteria

Chrysmela Secure Earring backs

Whilst these may seem expensive, these earring backs are said to be the most secure backs you can find and it’s better to be safe than sorry. They work by gripping the earring post and hold it really securely. This particular type has a pad to spread the weight of your earring and not pull on your ear – therefore they are perfect for earring piercings that appear “droopy” with certain earrings. As these back are so secure, they are perfect for wearing with diamond studs.

Earring Lifts for Droopy Ears and Stretched Earring Holes. Secure Earring Backs by Chrysmela Platinum Finish. Fit and Lock Most Earring Posts. Replace Earring Screw Backs, Butterfly Backs, La Pousette
Buy on Amazon

Screw Backs

Limerencia Hypoallergenic G23 Implant Grade Titanium Screw Back Earrings Tragus 20G Helix F136 Piercing Post for Sensitive Ears Simulated Diamond Cartilage
Buy on Amazon Primeeligible

Screw backs were generally used with more expensive stud earrings, such as diamond solitaire stud earrings. They are also frequently used on children’s earrings.

A screw back is more secure and can’t slide off the post as butterfly or scroll backs could. 

As the name suggests, the earring post has a thread running around the post and the earring back, called a clutch or ear nut, is wound around the post just like a nut.

These earring backs state that they are the most secure earring back, ever, and use a patented technology that says it locks and lifts the earring.

As you slide the earring back onto the earring post, three tiny ball bearings inside the Chrysmela earring back grip and lock the back onto the post. To release you pull back on the endplate and it releases the lock. 

Chrysmela earring backs can be used on any earring post from 0.6 mm to 1.1 mm thick, as the micro ball bearings adjust to fit any size post.

They are hypo-allergenic with any part which touches skin being plated in either platinum, 24k gold or rose gold.

The inner part of the earring back is made from surgical steel. 

Pro’s

  • Extremely secure
  • Can be used on all earring posts
  • Should last for decades

Con’s

  • A considerable expense

LOX

 

Connoisseurs Lox Silver Tone Earring Backs LOX 2SDP
Buy on Amazon Primeeligible

Lox are a fantastic invention and our customer’s love them.  In our opinion, these are the best locking earring backs and are resonably priced.

An engineer created them after his wife lost her favourite earring on their driveway outside their home.

While they searched extensively for the earring, they never did find it.  LOX are universal earring backs that were created to solve this not-infrequent and upsetting problem.

You merely slide the LOX earring back onto your earring post and stop where ever is most comfortable for you. The earring back grips rigidly to the post.  The secured back will not budge, even with some degree of pressure.

To remove the backs, you grip the little metal and plastic levers and squeeze which releases the hold on the post and the back easily slides off the earring post. Fantastic! 

LOX come in gold-tone or silver-tone hypo-allergenic metal and you get two pairs in a pot. They can be swapped and used on any of your earrings. 

Because LOX earring backs slide on and ‘grip’ the earring post you may find that they make miniscule scratches on the earring post, particularly on softer metals such as gold, although you would have to look for an eye loupe in order to notice them.

I use these earring backs on my own diamond solitaire earrings and I figured it is a tiny price to pay for not losing a diamond solitaire earring and the cost and hassle of replacing it. 

At worst,  I could have the gold post recovered in gold,  although it’s unlikely this will ever be necessary.

I’ve been using the LOX earring backs for nearly three years and the marks to the post are very slight. 

Pro’s

  • Easy-to-use
  • Hypo-allergenic
  • Interchangeable between earrings
  • Easy-to-use

Con’s

  • May mark earring posts

Clip-On Earrings

QUKE Women CZ Crystal Snowflake Shape Clip On Stud Earrings Non Pierced Earrings For Women Girls

You don’t see that many earrings around which have clip-on backs.  Therefore. they are much sought-after by those who don’t have their ears pierced.

Easy to wear even for those who have pierced ears.

They have a flat piece which closes by way of a hinge positioned at the bottom of the earring. 

As clip earrings are so easy to put on and take off, they are great for those who have a busy lifestyle. 

Pro’s

  • Easy to put on and take off
  • Perfect for the less dextrous
  • No separate backs to loose
  • Kinder to ears with heavier earrings

Con’s

  • Harder to find
  • Can pinch if a tight fitting clip

French Clips or Omega

LeCalla 925 Sterling Silver Omega Back Earrings Medium Large Bar Dome Pierce Caviar Clip-On Stud Earrings for Women 16 MM

 

 

These are a cross between a clip-on earring with a pierced fitting.

They close from a hinge at the bottom of the earring and have an open oval shape which the post of the earring sits into, in fact the shape is exactly like the Greek letter Omega, from which their name (or one of them) is derived.

These are great earring backs, they are comfortable to wear and look great but, sadly, you don’t see them being sold on many earrings these days.  

Pro’s

  • No backs to lose
  • Incredibly comforable
  • Easy to put on and therefore perfect for those less dexterous

Con’s

  • Can pinch a little if the hinge is tight

Earring Backs For Extra Support

Plastic Ear Backs Pads

These round earring backs are large plastic pads which you place against the back of your earlobe as you put your earring on that provides an earring backing with extra support for larger, heavier earrings. They are also available incorporated into a clutch-type earring back (see image below).

These are easier to hold and have a smooth application onto any post. Just like the Push-On Stopper’s but with an extra supportive plastic pad.

pewterhooter® 5 Pairs of Comfortable & Secure Earring Backs

Buy on Amazon Primeeligible

Pro’s

  • Suit most pierced earrings
  • Extra support
  • Great for heavier earrings

Con’s

  •  

For Drop Earrings

French Wire

silver disc drop earrings with hook backs

Also called hook earrings because they are just that, a wired hook in silver, gold or other metal which bends up and over.

They are balanced by the weight of the earring hanging from the bottom of the wire at the front.

A great addition to hook earrings are  Plastic Earring Safety Backs for Hook Earrings (below)

Pro’s

  • Easy to insert
  • Easy to wear

Con’s

  • Surprisingly easy to lose

Plastic Safety Backs for French or Hook Earrings 

These fabulous little plastic cylinders slide on to the end of your hook earrings and stay in place.

This means that, if you get the earring caught and the hook begins to slide out of your ear, the plastic will hold the hook in your ear before you lose the earrings.

Having lost one of my favourite earrings on a train once, I wish I had been wearing some of these on my hook earrings. You sometimes don’t realise how much you love a pair of earrings until you lose one.

500 Pieces Clear Rubber Earring Safety Backs for Fish Hook Earrings
Buy on Amazon Primeeligible

Pro’s

  • Unnoticeable when worn on hook
  • Great protection against loss

Con’s

Latch Backs or Saddle Backs

You see these more with hoop earrings – the post, often with a little flick at the end, sits or clips into a curved saddle shape to hold the post to the other end of the hoop. 

These are secure but can loosen over time – ask your local jeweller to tighten them a little if they become loose.

Pro’s

  • Easy to use for the less dexterous
  • Very comfortable
  • Can be tightened

Con’s

  • May loosen over time

Leverbacks or Continental Fitting

coeur de lion leverback earrings

These earring backs are used on drop or dangle earrings. 

These fittings are hinged at the bottom with a spring which closes the earrings back against the wired which goes through the ear.

They are very secure and perfect from medium to long dangle earrings. 

Pro’s

  • Secure

Con’s

  • Can be fiddly to insert

How to Tighten a Butterfly or Scroll Earring Back

As already mentioned butterfly backs can become loose with repeated use leading to them sliding easily on and off the earring post where it won’t grip as it used to.

Therefore, it is easy to lose an earring back. 

These can be tightened, but it needs to be done with some care. The “scrolls” of the earring backs can be gently squeezed together – either ask your jeweller to do this for you or do it yourself. 

If you do this yourself, you will need a pair of fine-nosed pliers, inserting the end into each scroll and, gently, turning or twisting the pliers towards each other until the desired tension is achieved.

Where Can I Replace My Earring Backs?

Any jewellers will have spare earring backs in stock.

Butterfly backs should be easy to get hold of in silver, gold and plastic, as well as rubber earring backs. Gold earring backs are available in 9ct or 18ct in any coloured gold including 18ct white gold earring backs.

Replacement French Wire hooks are also easily replaced.  

To Sum Up …

We recommend LOX, for two pairs they are excellent value and can be interchanged between your earrings.

When you add up what you’d spend on replacement butterfly backs, and also factor in the cost of losing an earring when a back has fallen off, they prove to be very cost-effective. 

Chrysmela claims to be the most secure earring backs ever, although they are a pricier choice. Well worth it, though, to keep a pair of beloved earrings secure.

We hope this has taken some of the confusion out of the subject of Earring Backs and you are clear on what to replace a lost earring back with next time it happens.

As always, let us know your experience with different earring backs or if you have any questions about them. 

Leave a Comment

Subscribe to our newsletter

This is little Darcy, our miniature Schnoodle, who helps us around the office, ensuring we take regular breaks to throw here ball.
Please also indicate the other subjects you’re interested in below and we’ll only send you what’s relevant. 

Subscribe

* indicates required
Interests
Please select your interests